Robert D. Morningstar ©

About the Author:

Robert D. Morningstar is a computer systems and imaging specialist living in New York City. During the 1960 campaign, RDM worked as a volunteer for the election of John F. Kennedy in NYC. He is a graduate of Power Memorial Academy with a degree in psychology from Fordham University. RDM is an acknowledged Tai Chi master and has taught for the East Asian Studies Department at Oberlin College and as an Adjunct Lecturer at Hunter College (1994-95), City University of New York. From 1992-1994, he was a movement therapist in the Behavioral Sciences Department at The International Center for the Disabled teaching in Stress Management and Behavioral Modification Programs in New York City.

Morningstar is also an FAA licensed pilot and Instrument Ground Instructor. He is a member of The U.S. Naval Institute, The Air Force Association, the Aircraft Owners and Pilots Association and the Air Safety Foundation. His biography is listed in “Who’s Who in The East” (24th & 25th Editions).”

R. D. Morningstar has studied the assassination of John F. Kennedy since the day it occurred. In 1992, at the Third Decade Symposium on the JFK Assassination in Chicago, R. D. Morningstar became the first scientist to expose publicly the use of gestalt psychology in the alteration and doctoring of the Zapruder Film.

In June, 1997, RDM was elected Presider of the Ancient Druid Order of England in a Druid ceremony at Stonehenge directly linking him spiritually to the Arthurian legacy.

As we approach the 35th anniversary of the death of JFK, Robert D. Morningstar is proud to present to all Americans yet cherish truth, liberty, and freedom of speech, in memory of President John F. Kennedy, “The Ultimate Secret”:


“Once you have eliminated the impossible, what remains, however improbable, is the Truth”-

Sherlock Holmes.


The JFK-Tippit Double Murder

“The killing of Officer Tippit is the Rosetta Stone of the JFK assassination”

– Wesley J. Leibeler, Warren Commission counsel


For 35 years, the world has wondered about the circumstances surrounding the John F. Kennedy Assassination. The facts of the case lay in murky darkness mired, like a body sunken in a bog awaiting resurrection or revival.
For 35 years, having been a witness to these historical events, I have collected the facts surrounding that singular moment in our dark history in the hope of someday bringing the truth to light. I did this for one reason and one person only. The quest has lead me across continents and oceans, even back to Camelot. I have descended into the underworld. I have communed with the dead. I have drawn the Sword from the Stone to redeem the soul and restore the body of a Celtic king to his rightful place. The journey is dangerous but the reward is to arrive one day out of darkness into light.


I forewarn the reader that what follows is a story so ghastly that it would be worthy of Mary Shelley, Bram Stoker, or H.P. Lovecraft. However, for us it is far worseit is true. What follows are the actual facts culled from the bog which we have come to call The Warren Commission Report.


“And I saw one of his heads as it were wounded to death; and his deadly wound was healed; and all the world wondered after the beast. And they worshipped the dragon which gave power onto the beast, saying, Who is like unto the beast? Who is able to make war with him?”

—The Revelations of St. John The Divine, 13:3-4.


My fellow Americans, The President of the United States, the real John F. Kennedy.


On June 26th, 1992, in Chicago, I was invited by Mr. Douglas Carlson to address a closed session of Kennedy assassination researchers at the Third Decade JFK Symposium on my discovery within the Zapruder Film several alterations which employed what I have dubbed “Gestalt Editing Techniques”. I also reported the discovery visible condensation trails in Frame Z-295.

The discovery of this condensation trail by this writer in New York City and independently by researcher Roy Schaeffer in Dayton, Ohio in 1992, proves conclusively the presence of a shooter high on the Criminal Courts Building.


It was while preparing for the Chicago lecture that one of my research associates asked me, “Robert, where was J. D. Tippit shot?”

“In the left eye, I believe…” I replied, for that was the story I’d read in the New York Times many years before. “But”, I added, qualifying my reply, “let me make sure.” At that moment, Jim Bishop’s “The Day Kennedy Was Shot” was on my desk at arms length, and I read the section on the death of Officer J. D. Tippit.

J. D. Tippit was the Dallas policeman murdered on November 22, 1963, 45 minutes after the shooting of JFK. Tippit’s murder was immediately pinned on Lee Harvey Oswald.

Tippit’s killing has always been pictured as a chance encounter in the Oak Dale District between an alert, cruising (hero) policeman and a “suspect” in the shooting of JFK based on the APB (all points bulletin) put out minutes before by the Dallas Police Department. His assassination has always been pictured as a random killing forced by circumstances on the fleeing Oswald. I recalled that he had been buried the following day (November 23rd) in a sealed casket because his wound had purportedly disfigured his face. Tippit’s body disappeared from 10th and Patton that afternoon (1:15 p.m. November 22nd), was processed through two hospitals within 2 hours, and was never seen again by kith or kin. I remember his funeral shown on CBS, a light bronze coffin was laid to rest surrounded by many mourners, Mrs. Tippit, their 3 children and waves of weeping policemen.


In Jim Bishop’s account, much to our amazement, besides being shot in the torso several times, Tippit as was described as having been shot the right temple, specifically the right temporal area, the very same region of the head where the fatal shot passed through President Kennedy.

I was stunned. My mind boggled at the thought that this might be a mere coincidence–that the man accused of killing both Tippit and JFK could shoot 2 people within 45 minutes of each other, within 4 miles of each other, one with a rifle from a high building and one with a handgun at short range (on the run), and inflict exactly the same type wound. I resolved to inquire about this of experts in Chicago.


I had already read of some unusual medical discrepancies between photos and x-rays of the President in several books, which I recommend highly. These included Harrison Edward Livingstone’s “High Treason II” and David Lifton’s “Best Evidence”, others are mentioned in the body of this report. His report uses the lexicon employed by Livingstone in “High Treason II” in the autopsy photo analysis in acknowledgement of Mr. Livingstone’s great Contribuyions to the JFK medical debate.

At the Third Decade conference, at a panel of the country’s foremost experts on the Kennedy assassination, I inquired whether anyone there had ever considered the possibility that we might be seeing rear view photos and X-rays of Tippit substituted for those of JFK, based on the amazing similarity of the temporal head wound in both victims. Some cynics laughed in the audience but from the podium, the moderator, George Michael Evica, author of “…And We Are All Mortal”, responded with a most unusual answer:

“It’s interesting that you should ask this question because…I’ve studied Tippit, and when I went down to Dallas I found out that Tippit bore a remarkable resemblance to President Kennedy, so much so that HIS FRIENDS IN THE DALLAS POLICE DEPARTMENT USED TO RIB HIM AND CALL HIM ‘JACK’ AND ‘JFK'”. (emphasis mine)

I then inquired whether anyone had ever seen any pictures of Tippit other than the one I had dubbed “The Tippit-Elvis Picture,” which showed him in a cowboy shirt, head slightly tilted, hair slicked back, appearing to be about 26-28 years of age. To my knowledge, it was the only one that had been published since his death. I also inquired whether anyone there had ever seen Tippit’s autopsy report or knew his personal history. Later, Dan Du Pont, a researcher from North Hollywood, CA, approached me to discuss my inquiry. He promised to send me a copy of Tippit’s autopsy report to assist in my research.


In late July of 1992, I received from Dan Du Pont a 1964 manuscript by Gary Murr entitled “The Death of Officer J. D. Tippit”. It contained the report of FBI Special Agent Arthur Carter on the autopsy of Officer J. D. Tippit, conducted by the Texas Coroner, Dr. Earl Rose. While studying the entry wound diagrams by Dr. Rose, I saw a remarkable similarity between Dr. Rose’s Tippit diagrams and the wound I perceived in the purported JFK lateral x-ray. I realized that the lateral x-ray purported to be that of the late President might in fact be that of Officer J. D. Tippit.

Rose Autopsy Diagram. Compare with the purported JFK X-ray (left).

Dr. Rose’s description of the path taken by the bullet through Tippit’s brain approximates the trajectory described by the Warren Commission and House Select Committee on Assassination reports of the bullet’s path through the late President’s brain.

In the enlargement below, the red arrow depicts the path followed by the missile as described by the autopsy team.

This further correlation with JFK’s head wound indicated that we had uncovered a very significant omission of the Warren Commission Report.


Furthermore, while comparing Dr. Rose’s autopsy of Tippit with Humes’ and Boswell’s autopsy report on the President’s brain, I noted that both autopsies described the lacerations severing the same brain parts, the “cerebral peduncles”.

This is a part of the midbrain, which could not have remained intact and recognizable in President Kennedy when we see the head wound sequence depicted in frame Z-313 ff. in the Zapruder Film. The eyewitness testimonies of Dr. Kemp Clark, Malcom Perry, Dr. Charles Crenshaw and others at Parkland Hospital, and eyewitnesses on Elm Street and near the Grassy Knoll are at great variance with the head wound depicted in the Stare of Death photos and “The Back (F3)” close-ups. Nor do they tally with drawings of the head wound used by the Warren Commission and its henchmen to dupe the doctors at Parkland Hospital and many other medical experts in the intervening years since the death of the President Kennedy.

I found few differences between Rose’s report of Tippit’s brain and that of Humes, Finck and Boswell for JFK’s brain. One was the weight, the others were the presence of a “parasagittal laceration from the optic lobe” to just behind the orbit of the right eye, and the severing of the corpus callosum of the victim in Bethesda. This cannot easily be explained as the result of the passage of a bullet.

However, both these lacerations could be those described by Rose as the autopsy incisions performed during Tippit’s autopsy: the parasagittal laceration was an “intermastoid incision” performed to determine the trajectory of the bullet and to retrieve it from Tippit’s brain. The severing of the corpus callosum may have been a consequence of the removal of Tippit’s brain from the cranial cavity. The damage to the skull of J.D. Tippit described by Dr. Rose matches the lateral x-ray of JFK exactly.


I then decided to compare the purported X-rays of JFK with photos of both the President and Tippit. By properly sizing transparencies of the two men and comparing them, it became evident that Tippit and JFK, from the cheeks down to the jaw, were in appearance almost fraternal twins (see below, Tippit in Police Uniform/JFK at Love Field). When viewed from the side, there was, as George Michael Evica had stated in Chicago, “a remarkable resemblance.”


I then proceeded to compare the x-rays with photos of both men, and found that the intact portion of the purported JFK x-ray fit the skull contours of J. D. Tippit, but not that of JFK.

While conducting the skull contour studies, I realized that I could recreate an analog of an undamaged skull x-ray mimicking an undamaged contour by mirroring the intact half of the skull in the purported JFK x-ray. I later mirrored the damaged half as well, creating a facsimile of symmetrical damage to both sides of the skull, dubbing it “Total Destruction”. This would later confirm the fraudulent nature of the famous “Stare of Death Photos,” first exposed by Harrison Livingstone in “High Treason II” (HT2).

In the interest of simplicity, consistency and in appreciation of this significant work by Harrison Livingstone, we employ much of the vocabulary and lexicon that he established (in HT2) for the medical evidence in the analysis which follows.


Reproducing transparencies of the x-rays, bisecting them, and aligning them along the nasal septum, I produced a “Reconstructed Skull X-Ray of President John F. Kennedy” seen here:

This revealed that the x-rays are not those of he skull of the President. Although JFK and Tippit bore a close facial resemblance, the differences between their skull contours and hair lines. In the right three-quarter profile comparison of JFK and Tippit , it is obvious that President Kennedy had a much larger cranium–thus explaining the discrepancy between the x-ray contour and the photo of JFK. The skull x-rays are those of Tippit, after removal of the fractured bones of the frontal and temporal area.


In 1993, Dr. Jerry Rose of the State University of New York at Fredonia informed the writer that the Dallas Police Department lost track of Tippit’s body for over an hour, because he was removed from the murder scene by an ambulance before police arrived. Another strange and suspect fact is that Officer Tippit seems to have had bullets removed at two different locations. First on the way to Methodist General Hospital, where some bullets were purportedly removed in the ambulance. Then at Parkland Hospital by Dr. Earl Rose, who describes removing the same bullets supposedly removed at Methodist General, where he had been pronounced DOA. Why was he moved, then, to Parkland Hospital?

The Texas Coroner, Dr. Earl Rose, argued with the Secret Service over custody of the President Kennedy’s body until 2:08 PM, when the Presidential party departed Parkland, absconding with the body. Despite this, Dr. Rose reported completing Tippit’s autopsy at 3:15 PM. I thought this a little quick until I read, in Dr. Charles Crenshaw’s “Conspiracy of Silence,” of Rose’s boast that “We can have him [Kennedy] out of here in 45 minutes.” It appears that Dr. Rose was working under time pressurebut who is “we”?


We come now to the most disturbing discovery of this on-going investigation. I have uncovered evidence suggesting that it is not President Kennedy who is buried in Arlington National Cemetery under the Eternal Flame.

The testimony of the closest eyewitnesses indicate that it is not JFK but very likely J. D. Tippit.

As shocking as this may seem, consider the words of Senator Robert F. Kennedy as he viewed the body in the open casket. William Manchester reports that as RFK looked at his “brother” for the last time, he said:

“It doesn’t look like him at all”.

This writer goes much further: “It isn’t him at all!”


This photo is pure theatrics and cosmetics. Much of the horror fades away when one consciously begins to ignore the “subliminal swaztika” which the cosmetics artists imbedded within the dark area of the head, the hair, hairline, and “The Devil’s Ear”. This creates an embedded psychic disturbance to frighten the viewer of this photo and to distract him as well from discerning the actual identity of the victim. Creating a right angle to complete one corner of the “subliminal swaztika” may well have been the purpose of “The Devil’s Ear”.

How else can one explain the transparency of this fraud and the successful duping of scores of medical experts all the way up the A.M.A. ladder to Dr. George Lundberg. Dr. Lundberg is the President of the A.M.A. whom I personally observed defending the WCR conclusions during the Medical Panel of the Third Decade Symposium in Chicago in 1993. Hissed and booed by the irate crowd, Dr. Lundberg defended the WCR conclusion as best he could but was soon drowned out and swamped by the venom of the crowd and the vitriolic eloquence, rhetoric and wit of Dr. Cyril Wecht.

“And I saw one of his heads as it were wounded to death; and his deadly wound was healed; and all the world wondered after the beast.”

I had to ask myself: “Could this scene of pandemonium in Chicago be the actual fulfillment of that strange and mystifying prophecy of the Revelations of St. John?” There were we all truly marveling at “the head of the beast” as it had been wounded to death yet we could not reconcile how “the deadly wound was healed”. I turned to Randy Robertson, a radiologist with more than passing interest in the case and said, “The problem is that these people are all arguing about x-rays and photos that are not those of JFKTippit was shot on the same side of the head as JFK. I think we’re looking at pictures of the back of Tippit’s head.”

Another “true believer”, for more than three decades, has been Dr. John Lattimer, whom I debated at the Bay Shore Historical Society in Brooklyn, New York on November 16, 1994. Dr. Lattimer, the eminent urologist to Lyndon Johnson, seems to have sworn a loyalty oath to Johnson and the Single Gunman Theory, much like Herman Goring, whose family signet ring Dr. Lattimer wears as a personal trophy from his Nuremberg days (as personal U.S. Army physician to the Reich’s Marshall). I did not ask him how he acquired it (nor why, to this day, no one knows how Goring retrieved the cyanide capsule from his personal possessions stored under security guard without “someone’s” help). When I pressed him for another meeting or another debate, he replied, “Well, I must be going,I’m up to my ears in Nuremberg? When I gave him a quizzical look, he added “The anniversary is coming up!”. However, after having seen the photos herein presented, though a bit startled, Dr. Lattimer had the graciousness (and honesty) to say: ” I must say that you have compiled the most compelling set of photographic evidence I’ve seenthank you.” With that , he turned and left for “Nuremburg.”

Pathetically, during the Medical Panel in Chicago, it was obvious that Dr. Lundberg, in complete honesty, really believed the so-called “facts” and the “medical evidence”. The Warren Commission Report is a collection of falsehoods regularly presented by the government to many intelligent and well-intentioned (but cognitively disadvantaged) medical experts all too willing to take what was presented as “evidence” at face value.

I had to admire his courage although I could not admire his flawed perception and gullibility. The indignant and self-righteous crowd was brutal on Lundberg , Lattimer and the SBT (Single Bullet Theorists) faction.

It was quite unjustified, in fact, for the jeering, booing crowd itself believed the photos and the x-rays to be those of John F. Kennedy and that their interpretation of same was “more” correct when , in fact, it was just as wrong! That is one of the bitter pills of disinformation taken as “Truth”: everyone is fooled; everyone is blinded; and, all are left divided. Agreement and consensus are impossible when arguing over nonsensical information. The blind lead the blind.


As I became more familiar with Tippit’s features, I began to see many distinguishing characteristics. There is one in particular which makes the identification conclusive. In “HT2”, H. E. Livingstone noted that the person in the “Stare-of-Death Photos” has a nose that does not resemble Kennedy’s, and that moles and facial hair seen in photos taken of JFK on the morning of November 22 are absent.

One detail Livingstone did not notice is that, in addition, a mole which was not on JFK’s neck that morning mysteriously appears very prominently in the “Superior Right Profile (G1)” picture purported to be JFK. The proof of Tippit’s identity came when I noticed the unique black neck mole in the color version of the photograph. Due to the darkness and graininess of the black and white versions published in recent years, the true nature of the black mole was easy to overlook.

However, in the color version, the mole’s nature is clear. It lies on the right side of the neck, almost parallel to the base of the hyoid bone or “Adam’s Apple”. Though I had studied photos of JFK for ars, I could not remember ever seeing such a blemish on his neck, but on other photos of Tippit, the mole is plainly visible.

Furthermore, I discovered another unique ear mole pattern on Tippit’s left ear which matches the left ear mole pattern of the man in Fox Photo F4 (the “Left Profile” photo). Another search of photos of JFK turned up no such mole.


An investigation which began with a single photo of the deceased grew slowly as a team of investigators and supporters began to coalesce around my initial discoveries of the doctoring of the Z-Film and radically new theories on the assassination scenario. I searched for over a year for other pictures of Tippit, but with little success. No other pictures were forthcoming until September 1992 when I found a very rare right three-quarter profile of Tippit in police uniform (later dated by Larry Ray Harris as mid-1950’s) in a national magazine. Printed in the magazine the size of 2 postage stamps, I was able to laser copy and enlarge the photo for initial comparisons with the face of JFK. The photo below was further enhanced using the modern digital computers.


It was this second comparisonof the photo above with the photograph below of President Kennedy at Love Field on the morning of the assassination that convinced me that we had found the key and were on the right track.

Comparison of Jaw Structure first conducted in 1994 of Tippit (left) with that of JFK at Love Field on the morning of November 22nd, 1963


Two Tippit photos showing Tippit in casual attire, the Tippit-Elvis Photo (circa 1952) and the Tippit-1959 photo, both show the black neck mole as seen in the “Superior Right Profile” photo (G1) as well as those photos attributed to James K. Fox (F1).

I am grateful to Professor David Porter of Empire State College, who directed this investigator to this rare Tippit photo. I had long suspected that the Tippit-Elvis picture showed a man much too young to be the 39-year-old man killed on November 22, 1963. It was later confirmed by Tippit expert Larry Ray Harris that the Tippit-Elvis photo was taken in 1952, when Tippit was 28 years old. Why, one might wonder, would anyone want to hide Tippit’s real age and features from public scrutiny?


Following this discovery, the purpose and the need for the what is called by researchers (like H. E. Livingstone) the “Reference Black Triangle” became obvious. Although President Kennedy and Tippit bore a great likeness to each other in the bone structure of the jaw, brow, nose, and cheeks, there were distinct differences above the brow line. Tippit’s cranium was rounder and smaller.

The President had full, red-brown hair, Tippit had black hair and a pronounced receding hairline. In order to create the appearance of the same hairline in an area that had no hair, it became necessary to fake one of the same contour by surgically rearranging a section of scalp. The altered scalp and the underlying surface area were thus made to appear to be both hairline and the consequence of an actual wound. In view of this, the accuracy of the Sibert and O’Niell FBI report, discovered by David Lifton in the 1960s, becomes evident: “It was also apparent that a tracheotomy had been performed as well as surgery of the head area, namely, in the top of skull.”


In addition to the “Black Reference Triangle,” another artifact which has confounded medical researchers is the one called “The Devil’s Ear”. It is an unusual flap seen in the right temporal area of the victim’s head in both the Fox and Groden photos.

Dr. Rose’s autopsy report describes the entry of Tippit’s head wound occurring in the area between the ear and the brow. The purported “JFK Lateral X-ray” shows what appears to be a semicircular fracture at a point where the temporal bone joins the zygomatic process, between the ear and the brow. It is interesting to compare this characteristic of the JFK lateral x-ray with Dr. Rose’s description of Tippit’s wound. Dr. Rose describes it as “wound No. 1.” It was actually the fourth wound placed with surgical precision by Tippit’s killer after he approached the fallen officer to administer the coup de grace:

“No. 1 is 4 3/4 inches from the top of the head and 3 3/4 inches to the right of the midline. This measures 3/8 x 1/4 inch and is surrounded by a contusion ring.”

The missile proceeded “slightly upwards, backwards and to the left”. It caused extensive fractures around the temporal bone and surrounding areas. The bullet went on to strike the inner surface of the occipitoparietal bone (the rear part of the skull), also fracturing it extensively, “but it did not exit”. It was recovered by Rose in the area of the calcarine gyrus, where it exited the brain tissue but not the skull.

This path, when reversed, coincides with the Warren Commission’s description of President Kennedy’s head wound more closely than the eyewitness reports of JFK’s wound at Parkland Hospital, all of which describe a large temporal entry wound and a large exit wound in the right rear occipital area.

The HSCA’s “High Head Wound” photographs are most likely those of J. D. Tippit. One of the objections of experts to the High Head Wound Photos is the presence of clearly visible hair inside the entry wound. This would be impossible in a rear-entry puncture wound. The path of the bullet which caused Tippit’s head wound ended precisely where these photos purport to show the entry point of JFK’s high head wound.

Since the bullet struck the inner surface of Tippit’s occipitoparietal bone “but did not exit,” it is logical to assume then that the point of impact would demonstrate signs of depression on the external surface of the skull, with the scalp sinking into the area of the cavity and beveling on the inner surface.

Thus, not having been punctured or perforated, hair would naturally appear intact within the depressed area, as is clearly seen in the High Head Wound photos.


The true nature and purpose of the Devil’s Ear now clearly reveals itself. While the head wound of J. D. Tippit may be described as a simple, circular, puncture type of entry wound, the President’s entry and exit wound was of a different nature. The President’s head wound was clearly an explosive one, more characteristic of a fragmenting or exploding bullet.

In order to pass off Tippit’s wound for JFK’s, it was made to appear similar by using the same technique used to create “The Black Reference Triangle”. An area of scalp was surgically altered to create a flayed, bloodied area approximately equal in to that of the President’s mortal wound seen at Zapruder frame 313 ff.

However, when compared to the catastrophic damage done to the President’s head depicted in the Zapruder Film, one quickly realizes that the area of the Devil’s Ear is much too small to be the consequence of the explosive wound(s) seen at Z-313 ff..  Tippit’s real wound was altered and disguised to appear to be JFK’s mortal head wound.



In Fox Photo “F6”, the “Top of the Head Photo”, one can see clearly that, despite the overhead angle of the photo, the wounds on “JFK’s” torso are those of Officer Tippit.

In the “F6” photo, the wound on the right side of the chest perfectly coincides with Dr. Rose’s description of Tippit’s chest wound. Dr. Rose states:

“Wound No. 2 is 17 inches from the top of the head on the right chest. It is 4 inches to the right of the midline, above and slightly medial to the right nipple. It is 3/8 by 1/4 inch and is surrounded by a contusion ring. No powder tattooing is noticed.”

The wound seen in F6 is precisely situated and exhibits the same dimensions and characteristics as Tippit’s wound. This wound is in the wrong position for it to be the point of insertion for the right chest tube into Preident Kennedy. Dr. Charles Crenshaw, in “Conspiracy of Silence,” says:

“The doctors inserted the chest tubes into the President’s body by making incisions between the ribs on both sides of his chest in the mid-clavicular lines.”

This refers to the area around the collar bone, much higher than the wound depicted in the Fox photos. The chest tube incisions, which were linear, were then further opened and stretched by the insertion of trocars which preceded the insertion of rubber tubing. No such incision appears in these photos. The wound on the chest of this victim is too low and does not correspond with the position of the 2 cm. incision drawn by Dr. Boswell on the official autopsy face sheet to be President Kennedy. The wound appears in uncropped Fox photo F1 below.

This wound had previously gone unnoticed, due to its close proximity to the right nipple, with which it could easily be confused. However, when one looks closely at it one can see that it is too low too close to the midline of the body to be the right nipple.

There is also a deep fold of flesh visible in the overhead photos (F5 & F6) of “President Kennedy,” lower down and to the left of the centerline, which fits the description and the position of Tippit’s Wound No. 4, which was caused by a bullet that struck a button on his police uniform, driving it into his body.

Disinformation regarding Tippit’s wounds had begun early. As previously mentioned, I had read a New York “Times” report stating that Tippit had been shot in the left eye. Jim Bishop’s “The Day Kennedy Was Shot” describes a spurious head wound as being in the “middle of the forehead” in addition to the correct entry site previously described. This is also clearly disinformation handed on to Jim Bishop, as evidenced by the Rose autopsy report and diagrams.

Rose writes:

“Wound No: 4 on the left chest is 20 1/2 inches from the top of the head, 1 1/4 inches to the left of the midline. The wound measures 3/4 by 3/8 of an inch, is transverse and surrounding this is a 1/4 x 3/4 inch abrasion.”

The gash or abrasion of the fold of flesh visible to the left of the midline below the left side of the chest in Fox photo F6 fits this description.

In Fox Photo F5 (The Back):

Let us note an amazing coincidence regarding the position of the back wound in photo F5. This was a shallow wound from which no bullet was retrieved, and which was no deeper than the length of a finger when examined in Bethesda by Humes and Boswell.


This supposed wound was seized upon by Arlen Specter and the “Magic Bullet” theorists as the point of entry for their amazing missile. Gerald Ford assisted him in formulating his “theory” by altering the location of the entry site from the region of the third thoracic vertebra (between the shoulder blades) to “the base of the back of President Kennedy’s neck” (WCR) or the “right cervical region” (see A.P. article) with the stroke of a hand-penned note to Chief Counsel J. Lee Rankin.

Gerald Ford and Arlen Specter forged and tampered with the medical evidence “to force true” the Magic Bullet Theory. Without these alterations, their rationalizations for their deceit of an entire generation would have been self-evidently nullified. In order to contradict the testimonies of the Parkland Hospital medical staff, it is clear that the swapping of the photos of Tippit for those of JFK was done immediately after the assassination. It also means that this part of the assassination was planned well in advance as the lynchpin which would assure success.

In December of 1963, these photos were already being used to try to coerce, discredit, browbeat and, at last, to convince Dr. Malcolm Perry, Dr. Kemp Clark, Dr. Robert McClelland, and the Parkland Medical staff that:

  1. the throat wound was a wound of exit ;
  2. that they had completely missed the back wound (later moved to the “right side of the cervical region” by Ford’s fraudulent alterations);
  1. that the back wound was the entry point for the throat wound;
  2. that Dr. Malcolm Perry’s surgical technique in performing the tracheostomy had obliterated the evidence and proof that the throat site was indeed “a wound of exit”.

The hand written note by Gerald Ford was released in June-July of 1997 by the Assassination Records Review Board, the incriminating note was the subject of an Associated Press report by Mike Feinsilber which appeared on July 3rd, 1997 world wide. Below is a scan of the New York Times National News Briefs column.

This key change by Gerald Ford, which constitutes criminally altering assassination evidence and tampering, served the psychological purpose of making the “Magic Bullet Theory” not credible but marginally plausible. “The Magic Bullet Theory” stood like a house of cards tenuously supported. With the discovery of Ford’s self incriminating note, the stacked deck of the Warren Commission Report came crashing down.

The real back wound was described thusly in the official death certificate by Dr. Burkley, the President’s physician:

“a second wound occurred in the posterior back at about the level of the third thoracic vertebra.”

This statement refers to an area a couple of inches below the neck and between the shoulder blades, or scapula. When we study this photo alongside Dr. Rose’s description of the path followed by the bullet which caused Tippit Wound No. 2, we find an amazing “coincidence.” Dr. Rose states:

“The wound described as No. 2 is found to go between the second and third rib. The missile…is recovered slightly to the left of the vertebra approximately 16 inches from the top of the head, having pursued a course very slightly upward, to the left and backwards.” Is it not remarkable that the bullet which caused wound No. 2 in Tippit should end its flight at the fourth (4th) thoracic vertebra, the one directly adjoining the point of “entry” of Arlen Specter’s “Magic Bullet” in Kennedy’s body at “about the level of the third thoracic vertebra”? Is it not more likely that that we are really seeing is the point of entry of the course followed by Dr. Rose in the recovery of the bullets which caused wounds No. 2 and No. 3 from Tippit’s body?

In this context, the befuddlement of the autopsy team is quite easily understandable. Sibert and O’Neill report that

“Inasmuch as no complete bullet of any size could be located in the back or any other area of the body as determined by total body X-rays and inspection revealing there was no point of exit, the individuals performing the autopsy were at a loss to explain why they could find no bullets.”

I believe that Dr. Earl Rose had them. It is now known that Chief Jesse Curry of the DALLAS POLICE DEPARTMENT had some bullets in his “collection” of JFK assassination artifacts shown in the book which he published circa 1990-91 cataloguing his “assassination memorabilia”.

Regarding Ford’s alteration of the facts, I wold point out that there is a very significant difference between the third thoracic (the actual entry site between the scapulae (shoulder blades) and the region of the third cervical vertebrae in the middle of the neck.

All this was done in order to make the simple assertion that the missile “passed through striking no bony tissue” marginally plausible, but ot enough to uphold the Magic Bullet Theory.

This incredible scarring of history did not make the Single bullet Theory more plausible but “plausible enough” for the public to give the Warren Commission conspiracy the benefit of the doubt, temporarily.  Within a year of the commission’s findings, the uproar started, causing the CIA and FBI to go into “Damage Control” mode.


Regarding the Right Superior Profile photo (G1), H.E. Livingstone wrote i  “HighTReason 2”:

“Although the sharpness of the nose may be due to the camera angle, the nose nevertheless does not appear to be Kennedy’s.”

I agree with Livingstone’s assessment. Furthermore, the nose ridges and shadows in Fox photos F1, F4, F6 and F7 also demonstrate that it is Officer Tippit when compared to the “Tippit-Elvis” and the William Allan photo of one of the arresting officers in the Tramp photos.

The “Left Profile Photo” (F4), when compared to Kennedy’s real profile, shows clear distinctions in structure.  See note below: Disguising Tippit’s Receding Hairline in Fox Photo F4).

The Livingstone-Groden Debate: The Divergent Eyes

Another consistent observation made by several witnesses who viewed earlier versions of the Stare-of-Death Photos is the divergence of the eyes in some these photos. Discussing the Fox photo (F1) in “High Treason II”, Livingstone writes:

“Note how wide the eyes are, yet the eyes are not divergent, nor is the right eye popped from the head as it was described by medical witnesses.”

This discrepancy again indicates that the individual in the currently available Stare-of-Death pictures is Tippit. The eyewitness account of Domingo Benevides, who saw the Tippit murder supports this theory:

“That is when I got out of the truck and walked over to the policeman, and he was lying there and he had, looked like a big clot of blood coming out of his head, and HIS EYES WERE SUNK BACK IN HIS HEAD, and just kind of made me feel real funny.” [emphasis added]


As mentioned above, I believe that the “surgery of the head area, namely top of the skull” described in the Sibert & O’Niell report refers to the Reference Black Triangle, which was used to hide Tippit’s receding hairline. However, Tippit’s receding hairline was nearly symmetrical, and so necessitated camouflaging on the left side also.

In Fox photo F4, “The Left Profile,” we can see that this was achieved by combing the hair forward and down from the area around the region of the coronal suture, near the ear line, which resulted in an artificial whorl of hair or “cowlick” in that region. If one looks closely, one can actually see Tippit’s bald pate beneath two of the combed hairlocks. Note that the angle of the sideburn is identical with that of one particular arresting officer, whom I identify as Tippit, in the Tramp photos.

Studying the profile, one can see two very distinctive nose ridges, one above the nose bridge, and another “notch” below the nasal septum, which President Kennedy did not possess, these are also readily discernable in the Tippit-Elvis photo. These ridges produced the “nose ridge shadows” which disproves the authenticity of Fox Photo F1 (the Stare-of-Death photo).


One of the the repeated challenges to the authenticity of the “Stare-of-Death Photo” and the Groden “Superior Right Profile” is the question of the alteration of the throat wound.

Dr. Malcolm Perry’s tracheostomy, as described by the Parkland team, is quite at odds with the long gash across the throat of the victim in these photos. Eyewitness after eyewitness has attested to the alteration of the throat wound. Dr. Charles Crenshaw, who witnessed Dr. Perry’s work firsthand, has described what is presented in the Groden frauds as “the work of a butcher”. Why was it necessary?

If we compare a close-up of the face of the arresting officer (Tippit) in William Allen’s “Three Tramps” photo with the President’s official photo, published on the cover of the New York “Times” on November 22, 1963, their similarity in jaw structure and other facial features is clear. But Tippit’s “laugh lines” and the furrow formed by a “scowl line” leading from the right nostril to the corner of the lips in a stretched “S” distinguish him from the President.


In the Groden-leaked photo, acne scars are visible on Tippit’s face on the the right cheek and two distinct ones along the scowl lines about 1/2 inch below and and 3/4 of an inch behind the corner of the right side of the lips. Tippit also bears TWO distinct moles below the right sideburn, one level with the middle ear and the other level with base of the opening of the auditory canal.

This pattern is also visible in the William Allen Tramp photo, and on the face of the victim in “Superior Right Profile.”

All of the details above:

  1. distinguish the right side of the face of J. D. Tippit from that of President Kennedy;
  2. distinguish the face of the real President Kennedy from the face of the victim in the Fox Photos and “Superior Right Profile (G1)”;
  3. confirm that the victim in the Stare of Death photos is Officer J. D. Tippit.



This leads us to the reasons for the Throat Slash (it can no longer be called a “tracheostomy”). It was plastic and psychological surgery.

The surgery had three purposes:


First, it produced a wound in the throat, because it the President had been wounded there, and Tippit had not been.

Second, it diminished the distinct jowls of Tippit’s double chin. The incision across the throat made the flesh of the jowls sag, tightening the flesh closer to the jaw line. This camouflaged the differences described above by softening the “laugh lines” and the furrow of Tippit’s scowl line, making him look more like a younger JFK.

The third purpose of the Throat Slash is the psychological aspect. The wound is designed to distract viewers from the obvious facts which expose the fraud. The shock induced by such a gruesome sight mesmerizes the viewer, freezes reason, and makes one’s logical thinking falter. Few people can look at these photos without feeling fear and dread at the thought that these atrocities could have been visited upon the President of the United States.

These photos were meant to fool medical experts of the time and future historians. They were also designed to instill fear into every citizen and into every President: a fear of asking the right question. They have been designed using Gestalt psychology to terrorize viewers into silence. The message is, psychologically speaking, an implied threat: if “they” could do that to the President of the United States, then what can they do to you, little man! A slit throat means silence–“ask no questions!” is the psychological message behind these photos. However, some Americans cannot be silenced that way.


Who could have perpetrated such an atrocity? It had to be a group (doctors & photographers) who knew what the President’s actual wounds looked like and one in close proximity to both bodies. Who had the authority to view and touch the President’s body, and who had the skill to execute the cosmetic surgery? Who was close enough to both bodies? Who had the opportunity and the authority to view the President’s wounds and those of Officer Tippit?

Given the official time frame of the Warren Commission, until recently we had to conclude that only two known men fulfilled the requirements: Texas Coroner Earl Rose and President Kennedy’s personal physician, Admiral George Burkley. The proof herein presented makes it self-evident that unknown physician(s) in Dallas altered Tippit’s body, with Rose signing for them.


The memoirs of Dr. Charles Crenshaw in “Conspiracy of Silence” shed much needed light on events at Parkland Hospital and reveal the roles of Dr. Vernon Stemmbridge, chief of surgical pathology, and Dr. Sidney Stewart in precipitating the legal battle between Dr. Earl Rose and the Secret Service over possession of the President’s body at Parkland. Stemmbridge and Stewart insisted that THEY had priority and legal jurisdiction over the President’s autopsy. Dr. Rose was apparently called in to affirm and defend their legal rights according to Texas law over the body of the fallen President.

It now appears very likely that someone other than Rose had autopsied Tippit by 1:45. Using the theatrics of Rose’s argument with the Secret Service over the President’s body as a diversion, JFK’s body could have been surreptitiously switched by the group who now evidently worked over Tippit’s body.


One of the bodies was placed inside a body bag, which could have been shipped in the right side cargo bay of Air Force One or on another jet separately arriving in Bethesda in a plain metal shipping casket.

Once the bodies were “in the bag”, it was easy to orchestrate shipment to Bethesda Naval Hospital via Walter Reed with Air Force and Army brass overseeing the theatrics which followed. Eyewitnesses reported seeing a helicopter take a body bag from the right side of Air Force One which then proceeded fly at ground level into a hangar at Andrews AFB.

Anyone who witnessed the proceedings at Andrews AFB on television as did this writer can recall the loud and powerful drone of unseen helicopters drowning out the voices of the reporters as they maneuvered in the darkness behind Air Force One.

Both bodies may have been transported to Walter Reed Army Hospital, where the JFK facsimile, using Tippit’s body, was completed. They were later moved to Bethesda Naval Hospital, where they were shuttled from one operating room to another as revealed by Harrison Livingstone in “High Treason II”.


The idea of the alteration of a second corpse never occurred to David Lifton nor Harrison Livingstone but that is easy to comprehend. Who, the devil, could conceive such a diabolical and twisted scheme? Anyone suggesting such a thing must be living in “The Phantom Zone”. The inability of these and other hallowed researchers and medical experts even to consider such an impossibility has lead many to receive some eyewitnesses’ testimony with leery skepticism and disbelief, sometimes ascribing the discrepancies to faulty memory, shock or some dark motive or agenda.


However, when one asks oneself “the right question”, the scenario described above becomes “a logical conclusion.”

The right question is: What is the logical conclusion if the eyewitnesses are all really telling the truth, accurately and factually?


There is evidence in the Air Force One tapes of an urgent telephone conversation between Admiral Burkley, aboard the President’s plane, and Army Surgeon General Leonard Heaton at Walter Reed Army Hospital. The contents of the Burkley-Heaton conversation are deleted. The audio tape jumps abruptly to other topics.

However, evidence uncovered and revealed by David Lifton in “Best Evidence” indicates that the missing conversations were discussing the recovery of the Harper fragment which was blown to the left side of Elm Street by the force of the blast from the Grassy Knoll shot.

This is where this investigation stood on November 22, 1996, in Dallas.


The history of this investigation is the story of a quest, a quest for understanding and reason in the face of mass confusion and mass deception. In time, a single thread was to lead this writer on a journey that has criss-crossed the continent physically, telephonically and electronically to recover the facts surrounding the most mysterious and occult deaths in our history.

The success that we have achieved in unearthing the truth about this barbarous affair could not have occurred without the moral and spiritual support which I have received from a cadre and network of many supporters around the world. These are the people who have helped to assemble small pieces of information, like those of a gigantic jigsaw puzzle, until enough small pieces coalesced and came together to produce this work.

What began with a single phrase in Jim Bishop’s book, within the course of few years had panned out and lead to the organization a network of researchers and “information surveyors” who ultimately as team procured the last piece of evidence necessary to confirm the “incredible” hypothesis presented above.


At the JFK Lancer conference in Dallas, on November 21 st & 22 nd , 1996, a long time friend and colleague in assassination research, Professor James Fetzer, McKnight Professor of Philosophy at the University of Minnesota and author of “Assassination Science”, informed me that he had succeeded in locating and recovering the Tippit autopsy photographs. Professor Fetzer promised to send me a xerox copy and a set of negatives.

Professor Fetzer had retrieved the photos in a most serendipitous fashion which he outlined in a recent e-mail to this writer:

” Robert,

Thanks for the email and the phone message. Of course I have no problem with your relating the history of how the Tippit photographs came into your possession, but I was the intermediary in all of this.

They were originally obtained from the National Archives by Frank J. Sarna III, who mentioned them in a letter to THE THIRD DECADE, which led me to contact him, obtain copies of negatives made from his copies, and reproduce the photographs locally, which I subsequently shared with youHe should get the lion’s share of the credit for this. When I subsequently visited the National Archives, for example, with box number in hand, they came up dry–the photographs were at that time not where they were supposed to be. I have learned from the ARRB, however, that they are now available so, presumably, it was simply an oversight that there were not available during my visit Best, Jim”

This was a momentous event for this writer. My theories and geometric proofs, as thorough as they were, had reached an impasse which could only be resolved by comparing the victim at Bethesda with actual autopsy photos of J.D. Tippit. I was ready to stake my reputation (or, as some thought, my life) on my geometric proofs but only the acquisition of the actual photos could make or break my theory.


They arrived a few weeks later. When printed and enlarged they confirmed what I had suspected for four years: the victim in the Stare of Death photos and in nearly all the government medical photographs was clearly the body of Jefferson Davis Tippit, they even share THE SAME EXPRESSION in jaw, cheeks, and mouth in BOTH sets of photos, one with eyes open, the other eyes closed. One with throat intact, the other, throat slashed. Inarguably, a perfect set of “before & after” pictures. Officer Tippit died with his eyes open (see Domingo Benavides’ testimony above).



It is interesting to note that this photo has been shot and cropped in a fashion nearly identical to the purported JFK lateral x-ray. When compared below, they clearly unmask the greatest criminal fraud of the 20 th century: both the x-ray and the photo are of the same person, Officer J. D. Tippit and conclusively NOT that of John F. Kennedy.


The contours of Tippit’s forehead and the frontal bone of the skull x-ray are identical. A semicircular entry point is visible in the x-ray which corresponds precisely with the wound site depicted in the Tippit Head Wound Close-Up shown above.

Another interesting point which confirms the identification the unity of the two specimens (skull and head) is that the jagged, irregular shape along the line of demarcartion between bright and dark regions of Tippit’s right forehead in the photo corresponds in shape to the major fracture line along the frontal bone and the missing portion of the temporal region in the x-ray. The subsidence of the fractured bone inside Tippit’s head created a depression along forehead and temple region which created a unique shading resulting in a light defraction pattern like an etching or a template.


As above, so below, the composite photograph demonstrates unequivocally that both corpses share in common, not only an identical expression around the features of the mouth, jaw and teeth, but the cheek bruises suffered by Tippit as he fell against the street pavement are visible in both. Closer scrutiny reveals the Tippit head wound entry site shown in the photos above to be present in the purported JFK photos as well though intentionally opaqued. These versions of the purported JFK Death Stare were enhanced by the writer by altering and increasing brightness, contrast, sharpness and gamma levels. This method made visible details which had been intentionally suppressed in order to pass the victim off as JFK.

The dark mole just above the right collar bone and seen immediately to the left of the throat wound was to this writer the key to realizing the victim’s true identity in 1994.


In addition, it is clear that the face of the victim was shaved and the eyebrows plucked. The redness and rawness of the recently plucked eyebrows is evident in the color versions of the “Superior Right Profile” Photo (see “The JFK Paradox). Researcher Tom Wilson has previously pointed out that the victim’s appearance indicated that it had been reconstructed around the temple using a wax-like substance (“The Men Who Killed Kennedy”, Pt. 5).



As shocking as this may seem, consider the words of Senator Robert F. Kennedy as he viewed the body in the open casket. William Manchester reports that as RFK looked at his “brother” for the last time, he said:

“It doesn’t look like him at all”.

Manchester’s account (in “Death of A President”) continues, “His eyes full, the Attorney General turned to Bill Walton and whispered, ‘Please look, I want to know what you think.’ Walton looked as long as he could, with a growing sense of outrage. He said to Bob, ‘You mustn’t keep it open. It has no resemblance to the President. It’s a wax dummy…Don’t do it’.”

Arthur Schlesinger said: “It is appalling,…At first glance it seemed all right, but I am nearsighted. When I came closer it looked less and less like him.”

And according to Manchester, Jacqueline Kennedy said, “It wasn’t Jack. It was like something you would see at Madame Tussaud’s.”


We have arrived now at a crossroads in history. The conspiracy before and after the fact stands exposed but justice has not been served. If I were we to end our history here on such a note it would be a ghastly tragedy. However, this is a story of a collective moral victory and the triumph of spirit over death, truth over deception, science over anti-science and light over darkness. It is the history of a small group of Americans driven by the power of spiritual insight and revelation toward moral restoration and a return to reason. It is the history of a people who do not give up their spiritual kinfolk nor forget their heroes, even unto death.

Though some might be tempted to think that the historical facts (above) which I have divulged might constitute what I have previously described “The Ultimate Secret of the John F. Kennedy Assassination”, they would be sadly mistaken. The actual “Ultimate Secret” in code is simply this: “The Spirit of Justice Does Not Sleep”.

The task remains: to achieve true justice for JFK, Tippit, Oswald, Kilgallen, and many others who gave their lives that the truth might live and eventually return to light.

For now, “The Ultimate Secret” must remain cryptic (as I am not yet fully liberated from the crypt of JFK) save to say until the day of justice for the fallen.

The Spirit of Justice Does Not Sleep therefore, I must speak for the dead.

 Robert D. Morningstar ©St. James CourtNew York CityNovember 11, 1998

Webmaster: R.J. DellaRosa —


“Rigged from ‘The Get’!” – How the Clintons and their Global Cabal  Communized the Democratic Party

Hillary Clinton Spanish posters inspired by Stalin

How the Clintons and their Global Cabal 


The Democratic Party

The Democratic Primaries were …

“Rigged from ‘The Get’!”

By Robert D. Morningsatar

I really wish we had gotten to see a Trump vs. Bernie contest. However, that did not happen because the Democratic Primaries were “rigged from ‘The Get’!.”
The Clinton cabal worked actively, covertly, and threw Bernie in as a “straw man” because it would have looked really bad for Clinton to run unopposed.
Little did they know that they had loosened a political lion upon the Democratic Party primaries.
Here’s a good sample  of a Sanders supporter::

Why I’m Supporting Bernie Sanders

Hillary Clinton Spanish posters inspired by Stalin
During the last election campaign, I analyzed the restructuring of the Democratic Party by the Clinton machine during the 1990s and I realized that the restructuring of the DNC and its primary system, a change in structure enforced by the Clinton-Gore machine (establishnig a new voting loc called “Superdelegates”) as a substructure wihin the Democatic Party was nearly identical in design (and intention) to  Stalin’s establishment of the Praesidium  and the Politburo in the Soviet Union to assure central control of the Communist Party, and central control of all elections acroos thenentire Soviet Union.
Shortly after its creatuion, the Politiburo replaced the Praesidium and came to dominate the entire Communist Party through its specialty, which  was reducing all elections to a One Candidate vote.
Image result for bernie photos
The recent revelations of how crooked Hillary was to Bernie Sanders by former DNC Chairwoman, Donna Brazile, proves beyond all doubt that that the Clintons stole the nomination  from Bernie Sanders and they went beyond legal bounds to insure it.  In doing so, Hillary Clinton and her staff broke several very serious Federal election laws, which will have even more serious consequences for the Clintons and their global cabal, as well as, the entire Democratic Party.
Robert Morningstar
November 3rd, 2017
New York City
Wiki-Historyof the Praesidium & Politburo
The Politburo (Russian: ПолитбюроIPA[pəlʲɪtbʲʊˈro], full name:
Political Bureau of the Central Committee of the Communist Party of the Soviet Union, abbreviated Политбюро ЦК КПССPolitbyuro TsK KPSS) was the highest policy-making government authority under the Communist Party of the Soviet Union.
The Stalinist system was based upon the system conceived by Vladimir Lenin, often referred to as Leninism.[2] Certain historians and political scientists credit Lenin for the evolution of the Soviet political system after his death.[2] Others, such as Leonard Schapiro, argue that the system itself, from 1921, evolved an inner-party democratic system to a monolithic one in 1921, with the establishment of the Control Commission, the ban on factionsand the ability given to the Central Committee to expel members they deemed unqualified.[3]
These rules were implemented to strengthen party discipline, however, the party continued under Lenin and the early post-Lenin years to try to establish democratic procedures within the party.[4]
For instance, by 1929, leading party members began criticizing the party apparatus, represented by the Secretariat headed by Stalin, of having too much control over personnel decisions.[4] Lenin addressed such posing questions in 1923, in his articles “How We Should Reorganize the Workers’ and Peasants’ Inspectorate” and “Better Fewer But Better”.[4]
In these, Lenin wrote of his plan to turn the combined meetings of the Central Committee and the Control Commission into the party’s “parliament“. <Super-Delegates> 
[4] The combined meetings of these two would hold the Politburo responsible, while at the same time guard the Politburo from factionalism.< meaning No dissent (factionalism) 
and “No Bernie Sanders” Allowed!>
[4] Admitting that organizational barriers may be inadequate to safeguard the party from one-man dictatorship, Lenin recognized the importance of individuals.[4] His testament tried to solve this crisis by reducing both Stalin’s and Leon Trotsky‘s power.




By Cherry Hinkle

(Copyright 2017, Cherry Hinkle – All Rights Reserved)



*Military Housing (mostly U.S. Army & Navy, but all other branches of the military are there too)

*VIP military Housing, including foreign military, !00% Off Limits to Civilians, including civilian Security Guards

*Military Research

*Listening Rooms, Sections One – Seven are strictly Listening Rooms for this facility.  Sections Eight – Two Hundred Thirty Six (229 sound proof Individual Rooms)

*VIP Lounges & Café, Military Mess Hall, Hydroponic Gardens, Kitchens

* Check-in facility for the Shuttle Train, also known as the “Sub-Global System.”  The very large shuttle depot, several gift shops, (it looks like any other western gift shop found anywhere in the southwest, nothing identifies Dulce Base or any other secret facility, a medical clinic. (it is common for travelers on the shuttle to experience motion illness.)

*One of the largest photographic laboratories on Earth.  That photo lab is 100% Off Limits to all Greys.

*On the western east sections of machine shops, including the machine shops or garages for the Terra-Drive machines.  These are machine shops that repair or build specific unknown flying objects.

*The garage for the UFO Fleet.  That fleet exits and returns to a sham cliff in near the town Dulce, New Mexico.

*Miles of climate controlled storage units.

*There are 56 acres of forest in the north western sections of Dulce Base.

*Tunnels to Taos, New Mexico and other points east.

*Tunnels to Creed, Colorado and other points North.

*Tunnels to Los Alamos, New Mexico and western points.

*Tunnels to Mexico City and other southern points

*Tunnels to Alamagordo, New Mexico, and southern points.

*3000 feet wide circular “nerve center” known as The Hub” the security central, many huge hanging transparent screens, similar to television screens, but as large as a movie screen, this is the control system for Dulce Base.

Any Many more classified materials, I cannot mention:


*This article is strictly reagding Level Two – and considered of ‘minor importance’ in this forty miles wide circular genetic facility.  As seen from the chart above, there are many more levels lying below Level 2.



Cherry Hinkle

New Mexico, USA


<Edited by Robert D. Morningstar>





By Norio Hayakawa

(Copyright 2017, Norio Hayakawa – All Rights Reserved)

Fluxliner ARV UFO 1

I began my research on the UFO phenomenon around 1961.  That’s more than 50 years of continuous study.

After more than a half-century of research on this topic, I can clearly state that the UFO phenomenon seems to be real, even though I have not yet personally observed what I can confidently say is a “UFO.”
But the UFO phenomenon does appear to be very real.
However, I can also state that UFO phenomenon does not constitute evidence of actual physical ET visitations by physical extraterrestrial biological entities (EBEs), piloting or maneuvering physical extraterrestrial spacecraft of any kind.
In fact, there is not a single physical, tangible, solid or credible documentary evidence whatsoever that we have ever been visited by physical extraterrestrial biological entities in any kind of physical extraterrestrial spacecraft.
 2016-04-01_9-46-56Photo (above) Purported to be the Dulce Alien Hybrid Laboratory was    Released by Capt. Thomas Castello, 1st man to leak the Dulce ET Base story.
By the way, Area 51 in Nevada and Dulce, New Mexico are two of my favorite topics.
I can confidently state that there seems to be no evidence of any UFO or “alien” connections to Area 51 in Nevada (which I have continuosly researched since around 1988).
The SR-71 Blackbird Near-Hypersonic Aerospace Plane …
Developed at Area 51
To me, Area 51 is a very important US Air Force’s research, development and testing complex for advanced military weapons systems integrated with avionics and aeronautics and continues to expand every year.
As far as Dulce is concerned, there is no evidence at all that there is a US/Alien collaborative biological underground facility or base in Dulce, New Mexico.
Yet, reports of sightings of strange objects seem to continue in the Dulce area, indicating that the phenomenon itself is active in that area.
Yes, as I stated earlier, the UFO phenomenon seems to be real. There is no question about it.
By the way, the phenomenon itself is not new.  It has existed since time immemorial.  There are historical records of people seeing strange objects in the skies, throughout history, such as “flying shields”.

Medieval UFOs over Nuremberg

The 1561 celestial phenomenon depicted above was a mass sighting of
Unidentified Flying Objects (UFO) above NurembergGermany.
 The depiction of the objects seen in the skies over Nuremberg in 1561, for example, seem to correspond to the cultural as well as technological level and  understanding of the people of each era.  In modern times, the objects seen seem to be more aerodynamic in form.
In the late 1700s and early 1800s, people reported seeing strange objects that appeared to be huge, rather crude-looking airships.
Later on, actual airships and other dirigibles were built by the U.S.
 U.S. Navy MZ 3A manned airship Naval Air Station Patuxent River
In the early 1980s when the U.S. was testing prototypes of stealth aircraft, there were many reports of humongous flying triangular craft over the East coast, which had nothing to do with prototypes being tested by the U.S. Air Force.
Mark McCandlish - Flying Wing UFO - Mstar enh
Triangular “Boomerang Type” UFO 
Courtesy of Mark McCandlish
Reportedly “humongous triangular craft” (sometimes reported to be 3 or 4 times the size of a football field) hovered absolutely silently in the night skies.
Mark MCandlish      Mark McCandlish speaking at Secret Space Program Breakway Civilization Conference   shows drawings of Alien Reverse Engineered Vehicles (ARVs) – San Francisco,  2014
 Many UFOs seem to be be secret US government projects, but emphatically, I say:
 No! …They did not all belong to the U.S. Air Force.
The UFO phenomenon seems to occur frequently in certain areas, such as Dulce, New Mexico, even now.
For me, here is the bottom line….and it may sound strange and stranger yet.
The phenomenon appears to me as a temporary paraphysical intrusion into our physical dimension by an unknown intelligence or unknown sentient entitities, paraphysically materializing themselves to a pre-selected observer (or a group of observers) and presenting itself to the observer as a physical phenomenon.
The pre-selection also seems to include a particular location, as well as, a particular time.
Chris Holly alien-life-forms
 The phenomenon seems to be able to materialize and de-materialize at will.
 Great researchers such as Dr. Jacques Vallee, John A. Keel and Dr. J. Allen Hynek all seem to be in agreement here).
However, the phenomenon does not seem to be able to survive in our physical dimension, except for a few seconds, or a few minutes at a time.
The phenomenon seems to be able to affect our physical parameters  temporarily (such as affecting radar, electronics, generating strong magnetic fields, and indications of radiactivity).
Yet the phenomenon also seems to be incapable of being photographed with clarity.   Now, here comes my personal belief.   You may totally be turned off by my rather religious-sounding belief, but here it is:
It is my belief that eons ago in the universe, there was a cosmic-shaking revolt led by an entity known as Lucifer and one third of the entire cosmic angelic paraphysical entities joined Lucifer in that cosmic revolt. Lucifer became Satan, and his followers “Fallen Angels”.
Satan and his “Fallen Angels” were thrown out from their special domain by the Creator and were hurled down towards our Earth.
But not all angelic entities followed Lucifer.  Only one third of the entire angelic entities in the cosmos joined forces with Lucifer, as I stated.  Lucifer became Satan, and his followers, “Fallen Angels”, malevolent and deceptive paraphysical entities.
In other words, to every malevolent “Fallen Angel”, there are two “benevolent” angelic entities.
The ratio is 2 to 1, two “benevolent” angelic entities for every one “malevolent” fallen entity.  There are “benevolent” entities present in this world, but for the most part, they are rarely seen.
Those are the ones who we often describe as “benevolent” angelic beings, doing good works and protecting us in many ways.
The “malevolent”, deceptive entities are the ones that are paraphysically materializing themselves and presenting themselves as physical “alien” entities from advanced extraterrestrial civilizations originating from outer space and piloting or maneuvering their extraterrestrial spacecraft.
Haxan Black Mass
No, they are not extraterrestrial visitors from outer space – – They are nothing more than the well-known extra-dimensional tricksters of old.
Believe what you will, but this is the bottom line for me:
They are the ones that are confusing people, deceiving people (by “posing” as physical extraterrestrial entities), and aimed at destroying the spirituality of people.
Norio Hayakawa
October 24th, 2017
New Mexico, USA
<Edited by Robert D. Morningstar>

Yang Style Tai Chi Ch’uan with Master Robert Morningstar

Yang Style Tai Chi Ch’uan with Master Robert Morningstar – New York City

 1 2 3 4
Tai Chi Ch’uan is the oldest of the Chinese martial arts. Tai Chi and Ch’i Gung (Chinese yoga) are the most ancient styles of exercise and physical culture employed to develop the human mind, body and spirit in an integral way to arrive at economy of movement, efficiency and peak performance (in whatever chosen field of endeavor).

Tai Chi is practiced slowly in a calm and relaxed way in order to attain perfect posture and a perfect gait. Many accidents and injuries are results walking or moving forcefully, but out of “alignment.”

Good health is essential to happiness, and physical fitness is essential to good health. We are all endowed with life, liberty and the pursuit of happiness. I hold the “pursuit of happiness” to be a civic obligation.

Tai Chi is also a renowned form of healing exercise, which helps reduce stress, anxiety, sleeplessness and works to repair and restore the body to health after illness or injury. This is achieved by retraining mind and body how to walk and move with ideal skeletal alignment in all phases of motion, thereby eliminating shock, stress and strain from everyday life. The results of Morningstar Tai Chi training are ease and grace in movement, physical and psychic development with an abundance of vitality, vim and vigor for Life.

Tai Chi Master Robert Morningstar is a disciple of the late Professor Cheng Man-Ch’ing, progenitor and exponent of the Yang Style Short Form Tai Chi Ch’uan. Prof. Robert Morningstar has practiced Tai Chi, Kung Fu, and Taoist healing arts, including acupressure and herbal remedied for more than 45 years. Robert offers private and group classes classes in Tai Chi Ch’uan, Ch’i Gung and “Anga Purna” (an ancient form of Kundalini Yoga – for adepts only).

Robert Morningstar is a graduate of Fordham University and has taught at Hunter College (CUNY), Oberlin College, and worked as Tai Chi Movement Therapist in the Behavioral Medicine Department of the International Center for the Disabled (1992-1994), applying Tai Chi and Ch’i Gung to physical therapy and rehabilitation.

Robert is also an internationally known investigator, lecturer, radio reporter who has appeared regularly on Coast to Coast AM, TV programs. Robert is the host of “The Morningstar Rapport” and “The Sounds of NYC News” on Revolution Radio and the Publisher-Editor of UFO Digest ( Robert is also featured in the film “The Professsor: Tai Chi’s Journey West,” a biography of Professor Cheng Man Ch’ing and appears in the upcoming film, “ETs Among Us – The Sequel.”

Private classes scheduled by appointment. Group classes are now registering to meet in Riverside Park (89th Street) and Central Park (60th Street & CPS) through the fall and winter.

For more information, call 212-496-1472
or send an email to ->

Las Vegas Videos Capture Images & Sounds of 2nd Shooter on Lower Level of Mandalay Bay Hotel


Primary tabs

Robert D Morningstar's picture

            THE LATEST UPDATE:


Las Vegas Video Images & Sounds Capture 2nd Shooter

on Low Roof of Mandalay Bay Hotel …

Sounds of Other Shooters Farther Away as…

Major Witnesses  Dying Off in Strange Ways 

As They Did in the Aftermath of the JFK Assassination

By Robert Morningstar

(Copyright 2017, Robert Morningstar-All Rights Reserved)

The Las Vegas Massacre is the worst gun related killing in the modern history of the United States. The nation is in shock.  The questions are many, the answers from authorities are few and not satisfactory or responsive to the many important questions being posed by the public and the press.

One of the primary questions is whether or not Stephen Paddock had help in carrying out the massacre.  Was he part of a wider plot?  Many witnesses and survivors of the shooting claim to have seen more than one shooter and to have heard more than one gun shooting at times simultaneously with distinctly different sounds and rates of gunfire and muzzle sounds.

The logistics of the attack also suggest that Paddock had help as a few hundreds of pounds in weapons, ammo and explosives were involved and very few people believe that Paddock (age 64) could have accomplished all the things he is said to have done to prepare his room for the attack, including lugging more moe than 20 weapons of various types, plus thousands of rounds of ammo and even high powered explosives in his car.

Meanwhile, authorities seem dumbfounded and slow (or loath) to react to eyewitnesses’ accounts while they are still  “floating” 2nd shooter debunking stories.

For example, The Sheriff said October 4th that what the videos show, i.e. capturing a 2nd shooter, was actually a strobe light or reflections. “It was a strobe light” mistaken for machine gun fire, or that people were “mistaking reflections from the windows of the hotel” for rifle fire.

The purpose of this article is to prove that what the witnesses and survivors claim to have seen and heard during that horrible ordeal was true and accurate:

There were multiple gunmen, at least 4, shooting up Las Vegas that terrible night, October 1st, 2017.  Two were shooting from the Manadalya Bay Hotel and the others attacked the front entrances of the Bellagio, Tropicana, Planet Earth, Hustler’s, and the Flamingo Hotel.

 Astronomy & Astrology of October 1st, 2017

With regard to astronomy & astrology, what we have on October 1st in the sky over Las Vegas was the approaching Harvest Moon (an ancient pagan feast day) and when viewed from the concert arena, the unique sight of the alignment of the star “VEGA” in the constellation Lyra in transit stationed precisely above the Black Pyramid at the time of the attacks .

The Star Vega:

Etymology and Cultural Significance

The term Al Nesr al Waki appeared in the Al Achsasi al Mouakket star catalogue and was translated into Latinas Vultur Cadens, “the falling eagle/vulture”.

The constellation was represented as a vulture in ancient Egypt, and as an eagle or vulture in ancient India.

The Arabic name then appeared in the western world in the Alfonsine Tables,[97] which were drawn up between 1215 and 1270 by order of Alfonso X.[98] Medieval astrolabes of England and Western Europe used the names Wega and Alvaca, and depicted it and Altair as birds.[99]Each night the positions of the stars appear to change as the Earth rotates. However, when a star is located along the Earth’s axis of rotation, it will remain in the same position and thus is called a pole star. The direction of the Earth’s axis of rotation gradually changes over time in a process known as the precession of the equinoxes. A complete precession cycle requires 25,770 years,[100] during which time the pole of the Earth’s rotation follows a circular path across the celestial sphere that passes near several prominent stars.

At present the pole star is Polaris, but around 12,000 BC the pole was pointed only five degrees away from Vega.  Through precession, the pole will again pass near Vega around AD 14,000.[101] It is the brightest of the successive northern pole stars.[11]


Small white disks representing the northern stars on a black background, overlaid by a circle showing the position of the north pole over time

The path of the north celestial pole among the stars due to the precession.

Vega is the bright star near the bottom. Since anicent times, Vega has represented a predator, an eagle or a “Falling Vulture.”  Vultures feed on carrion, i.e. dead flesh. Vultures also prefer open fields for preying.


Aerial view of Mandalay Bay, Las Vegas, Nevada.

I’ve corellated the videos linked below with this external photos of the hotel to triangulate the postion of the 2nd Mandalay Bay Hotel shooter who fired from a low platform atop the green roof porch shown above.

There were no broken windows in that area of the hotel.  Using the POV of the Taxi Driver as she was aligned with the corner of the roof structure that covers the drive through access road to determine the position of the 2nd shooter.  Below is video proof exposing the postion of the shooter(s):

The Las Vegas Taxi Driver’s Video caught a shooter firing from the lower floor of the Mandalay Bay from a very close vantage point, i.e., pulling out of the Mandalay’s Drive-Though entrance.

I believe that this is indisputable proof and is consonant with the 1st video that I posted on Facebook & Twitter earlier, i.e. the stable video shot from the hotel across the street.  I’ve compiled all the links together below.

1-  Las Vegas Shooting- The Taxi Driver’s Video

 Compare with:

2 – Video from the hotel across the street.

By freezing a clear frame of video taken by the Taxi Driver’s at the very moment when the camera captured the first muzzle flash and a section of the roof structure covering the hotel’s passenger drop-off entrance with external photos of the Mandalay Bay Hotel (see Aerial view of Mandalay Bay above),

By using the the cornered angles of the canopy roof structure that covers the hotel’s passenger drop-off area and overhangs /toward the exit road I was able to determine with precision the exact position of the vehicle and the camera angle to the shooter,

and thereby, place the shooter on the balcony that crowns the entrance, above and behind the “Green rooftop” seen in the arieal photo of the Mandalay Bay.

By comparing frames and correlating the driver’s position and the camera angle to the shooter’s position (indicated by the gun flash) in that frame, and using a triangular section of the unique roof (poviding two 90 degree angles for precise referencing,  I was able to calculate the shooter’s position to be outside the hotel and shooting from a balcony that covers the drive-through entrance of the hotel.

This explaiins how there would be NO broken windows on that level or that side of the hotel. However, windows are NO PROBLEM when the SHOOTER was standing OUTSIDE on a the balconuy of the roof that covers the entrance to Mandalay Bay.




3-  Crowd Scene and Sounds of 2 Automatic Weapons Fired at Same Time



(Posted by Arch Angel Studios – Published on Oct 5, 2017)

Listen to the audio closely and study the characteristics of the sounds that were recorded between Time Mark 4:39 and 4:52.  We can clearly hear the sounds of TWO (2) separate and distinct automatic weapons, each firing at a different rate of fire, one faster than the other.

The sounds coming from one of the weapons is distinctly louder (with the deeper sound of a higher caliber weapon than a .223 caliber/556 mm round).

Furthermore, one gun sounds much closer to the crowd in the scene than the other other weapon, which can be heard in the distance

If the listener plays the Arch Angel video sequence above (from 4:39 to 4:52), he will hear both guns firing at the same time.  The sounds and rhythm heard in the bursts of shots in different sequences are distinct in sound and with a different and disparate rate of fire to be heard between the 2 guns, one automtatic weapon firing much faster than the other.

The video proceeds with the sounds of sporadic fire in the far distance, but then again at time mark 12:33, we can hear the sudden and loud crackling of 2 automatic weapons firing simultaneously, which once again present distinctly different sounds to human ear and the discordant sequence of the firing proves again as in the previous section (4:39 to 4:52) that 2 guns are firing together simultaneously.  

However, let’s study this video and take note of  this very interesting detail:

In the sequence, (starting at 12:33) both guns begin to fire almost at the same moment (as if being directed by radio from a central coordinating command).

However, the difference in sounds prove (acoustically) that we are hearing 2 fully automatic weapons of different caliber and firing at different distances from the targt area and recording device.and the racket of  the 2 sounds clashing with each other, with an irregular pattern of mixed sounds, differing in intensity and in frequency of fire as they hammer out shots that are out of sequence with each other,  

The Other Hotel Attacks

Bellagio Las Vegas

The Hotel Bellagio

Eyewitness’ Video from the Lobby of the Bellagio Hotel

Lobby Virtual Tour

Below is a report by contributor, Alexandra Bruce (Forbidden Knowledge TV), regarding the reported “lock-down” of the Bellagio Hotel shown in the video below.

Alexandra Bruce wrote:

“I was alerted about this video by a subscriber whose brother drives a limousine in Las Vegas.  He’s spoken to several other drivers and bellmen at the Bellagio, the Flamingo and other hotels surrounding Mandalay Bay.  All reported that their lobbies were shot up last Sunday night.

This indicates that more than one gunman was involved in the horrifying events that evening.

My subscriber wrote,

“The hotels were on lockdown and shattered glass was all over the floors. A friend of his posted a video of the Bellagio lobby and people sitting in corridors because they were not allowed to leave…this was a coordinated effort.”

She was referring to the cellphone video above. It was taken from inside the Las Vegas Bellagio hotel and live streamed by René Downs to her Facebook account at 1:52 AM on Monday, October 2nd, a couple of hours after the Las Vegas shooting. By Wednesday night, over 1 M people had viewed this on Facebook. René’s comment on this video post is:

“This was NOT all done by 1 shooter. Watch til end. News and LVPD are not reporting this correctly.”

Read the entire article by Alexandra Bruce by clicking the link below:

******* reports:

The full Las Vegas police dispatch scanner audio has been released by Broadcastify, and it proves that first responder police confirmed that Stephen Paddock was not a lone wolf gunman, but received assistance from “multiple shooters at multiple locations.”

The scanner audio reveals that police received many reports from witnesses saying multiple people were shooting, and that Mandalay Bay security informed them there were shots fired from “floors 29 and 32.”

Besides the many eyewitness reports from members of the public, a police officer also urgently confirmed that there were at least two active shooters in the Mandalay Bay.

CONFIRMED there are at least 2 shooters with fully automatic weapons,” a police officer reported at 18:54 in the recording.

Multiple scenes then developed across Las Vegas, with police reporting and confirming multiple active shooters at the Tropicana and New York, New York Hotel-Casino (NY, NY).

CONFIRMED – Giles and Alibaba, casualties, East of the Catholic Shrine. SO WE HAVE TWO SCENES!,” said another officer at 38:30 in the recoding, confirming that there were casualties at Giles and Alibaba, a location out of range of Stephen Paddock’s gunfire from the Mandalay Bay.


Mike Adams: Forensic Acoustic Analysis

Acoustical Proof of 2nd Shooter

MIke Adams present a brilliant analysis of the acoustical evidence of the shooting to prove the presence of a 2nd shooter and his relative distance from the venue and the other shooter.

Click the link below to read the article and watch Mike Adam’s video:

Luxor pyramid and Las Vegas skyline at night. Las Vegas, Nevada, USA (color)


The Cryptic Charger

One of the unusual items discovered in Steven Paddock’s room was an electric  charger that did not belong to the deceased.  The FBI seized the charger and traced it to a man named John Beilman who lived inFairport, New York, a suburb of Rochester.

New York News Day reports:

“According to this report, upon the FBI searching the Mandalay Bay Hotel room used by CIA gun runner Stephen Paddock, a cell phone charger was discovered that had no accompanying phone—with SVR technology experts noting that this type of charger is used to charge a CP502520 3.0V 600mAh Li-MnO2 Non-rechargeable Thin Cell Battery used in various communication devices by both US Special Forces and CIA forces.

The company making this unique lithium battery, this report details, is Ultralife Corporation, based in Newark, New York, that specializes in military communications systems for the Pentagon—and whose lead engineer for this particular communication systems development was John Beilman.

Listing himself as a “product design and manufacturing professional”, this report continues, John Beilman was employed by Ultralife Corporation between 2007-2012 where he worked on various top-secret communications systems for the US military—thereafter his leaving to become a top engineer at the General Motors research facility located in Rochester New York.”

“The company making this unique lithium battery, this report details, is Ultralife Corporation, based in Newark, New York, that specializes in military communications systems for the Pentagon—and whose lead engineer for this particular communication systems development was John Beilman

Listing himself as a “product design and manufacturing professional”, this report continues, John Beilman was employed by Ultralife Corporation between 2007-2012 where he worked on various top-secret communications systems for the US military—thereafter his leaving to become a top engineer at the General Motors research facility located in Rochester New York.

Key Witness in Las Vegas Shooting Kills Self and Daughter

Following FBI Raid

“Fearing that Ultralife Corporation had been secretly funneling their US military communications systems to the CIA, this report notes, this past Tuesday (3 October), the FBI raided the home of John Beilman under a secret US Federal Court warrant—and that caused Beilman, less than 12 hours later, during the early morning hours of Wednesday (4 October), to wheel out his severely disabled daughter Nicole into his home’s backyard where she was executed, with Beilman then killing himself too …

And that was followed 48 hours later (6 October) by the Pentagon awarding Ultralife Corporation new contracts valued at over $49 million.

Investigators searched Beilman’s Fairport home the day before he shot his severely disabled daughter and himself, according to sources close to the investigation.

Agents executed a search warrant and raided Beilman’s Williamsburg Drive home the day before he took his daughter, Nicole, into the backyard and shot her and then himself in the back of the head with a 12-gauge shotgun.John Beilman’s 27-year-old daughter, Nicole, had Rett Syndrome, a rare neurological disorder.Nicole Beilman relied upon a wheelchair and was dependent on her parents for care.” — New York News Day


INFOWars – The War Room


In Conclusion

In closing,  I would state (unequivocally) that The Las Vegas massacre, the worst gun assault carried out against modern day America, was a well-planned terrorist act in which at least 2 shooters fired on a helpless crowd from the environs of the Mandalay Bay Hotel while at least 2 other gunmen (with drivers) attacked the Bellagio, New York, New Yorkand Flamingo Hotelswhich lie not too far away from the Mandalay Bay Hotel, about 1 and quarter miles away in the case of Bellagio.

“The terrorists used a method of assault that reveals a coordinated attack that is typical of Al-Queda, ISIS and The Zetas (the nefarious Mexican contract killers and narcotraffickers), all of whom are driven by an inveterate hatred of the United States and the American people.”

The Zetas? …


The reader may well ask: “Why the ‘Zetas’?”  Let us not forget nor overlook the importance and the implications of the  loud altercation altercation that occurred in the front of the crowd 45 minutes before the shooting began when a couple, a man and a woman,  were thrown out of the venue because they had been arguing vociferously with some other fans, during which time they repeatedly yelled at people in the audience, warning (or were they threatening?) them:

“Everyone is going to die!  You’re all going to die tonight!”

As reported by the Daily Mail:

“Brianna Hendricks, who attended the Route 91 Harvest Festival with her mother to celebrate her 21st birthday, described the moment a woman screamed “they’re all around…you’re all going to fucking die today,”

“There was a lady who pushed her way forward into the concert venue and into the first row, and she started messing with another lady, and told us that we were all going to die tonight,” Hendricks told KSNV.

“It was about 45 minutes before the shots were actually fired,” she continued. “But then she was escorted out by security.”

Hendricks and her mother left the concert before the shooting began, and heard the shots ring out just as they returned to their room.

“Obviously she was telling us that — either to warn us, or to warn us that we were all going to die and she was part of it,” Hendricks added.

Hendricks described the woman and a man she was with as Hispanic and about 5-foot-5.

When asked why the pair had been escorted out, Hendricks replied: “Because she had been messing with the lady in front of her and telling her that she was going to die. That we were all going to die.”



This sounds to me like an intentionally staged event. The Hispanic lady began “mussin” with another lady’s hair.  There is a video on YouTube showing this unusual event fom a distance and it appears that it was loud, and confrontal, but not violent.  The video shows  that a lady in front row had her hair up in a bun and the person in question began to push on her hair bun with her hand in an annoying way.  That’s when the fracas broke out, turned to shouting, aand a bi of shoving but without intensity as he woman’s partner, a man staning outside the reestraining fence and not standing in the audience. The shouting grows louder with the Hispanic woman uttering her warnings (or threatsz) ultimately bringing a security detail to stop the altercation by ejecting the couple, the Hispanic woman an her companion, and escorting them out of the venue withot any resistance or protest.

The shooting began about 45 mnutes later.  The scene appeared to be theatrical, as if it had been a skit already practiced and rehearsed right down to the calling of the security detail to escort them safely out of the venue as if nothing had happened, and strange even more, was that the security officer walk out leading to the exit with his back to the couple

Multiple eyewitnesses to the scene rendered the same or a similar description.  Those 2 people were not an Arabic couple, but an Hispanic-looking couple.


Las Vegas Police Statements: -> Paradox and Contradition

Las Vegas Police Statements Present Many Disputable Facts

Neon Nettle ( reported:–don-t-go-there-picked-up-on-mic-as-sheriff-asked-about-gunmans-car

“The sheriff caused a meltdown at the press conference when he suggested that Paddock “didn’t act alone”.“Look at this. You look at the weapon obtaining the different amounts of tannerite available, do you think this was all accomplished on his own, face value?”

 ‘Don’t Go There’ Picked Up On Mic As Sheriff Asked About Gunmans Car Las Vegas shooting investigation conference disected By: Daniel Newton  |@NeonNettle on 6th October 2017 @ 12.46pm © press

Ssheriff Lombard is asked a question relating to the Gunman’s Stephen Paddocks’ car.  Following the press conference for the investigation of the Las Vegas shooting, some YouTubers have discovered something unnerving in the video clip where Clark County Sheriff Lombard is asked about Stephen Paddock’s car.

When Sheriff Lombard is asked a question relating to the Gunman’s Stephen Paddocks’ car,someone allegedly whisper“Don’t go there”.

Lombard, who is visibly disturbed by the question responds “Don’t ask me to make assumptions, please”.


The Sheriff caused a meltdown at the press conference when he suggested that Paddock “didn’t act alone”.

“Look at this. You look at the weapon obtaining the different amounts of tannerite available, do you think this was all accomplished on his own, face value?”

“You got to make the assumption he had to have help at some point, and we want to ensure that’s the answer. Maybe he’s a super guy, superhero–not a hero, super–I won’t use the word. Maybe he’s super — that was working out this out on his own, but it will be hard for me to believe that.”

South Carolina Republican, Trey Gowdy, also mirrored Lombard’s theory when the host, Martha MacCallum, he was “skeptical” that gunman Stephen Paddock, could have acted alone without the help of another person. Gowdy also predicted that he would be “proven right” that Paddocks wasn’t alone in the coming days of the investigation.”

Read more at:–don-t-go-there-picked-up-on-mic-as-sheriff-asked-about-gunmans-car

With a Dubious Timeline, Now Amended … (Yet Again)

We should also take note that the trend in the current mass media news reporting cycle of “the official narrative” appears to be following a script of casting suspicion simultaneously on ISIS while at the same time propping up authorities’ comments denying the participation of ISIS in the slaughter.

In short, they are practicing Orwellinan “New Speak” and “double talk.”

Having watched these tactics employed for more than 50 years now, this writer recognizes such “New Speak” and “double talk” as a sign typical of CIA-MK-Ultra mass mind control methods used (many times before, facilitated via CIA’s Operation Mockingbird) to create confusion, i.e., cognitive dissonance, in anyone who is listening except those who are inured and can recognize such neurolinguistic programming techniques when they are being applied to befuddle, manipulate and distort public perception of events.  This kind of reportage was used throughout the the JFK/MLK/RFK Assassinations, and the during the 911 Attacks and in days following, particularly in regard to the Shanksville crsh site and and government obscuration of how that airliner really came down.

Essential Elements of a Terrorist Attack

Motivation, intention, resources, opportunity, stealth and proximity to the victim(s) are essential for a sucessful terrorist assault. 

As to motivation, intention and resources, these afoementined terrorist oranizations all share an inveterate hatred for the Unitd  States and the American people.

In that, they are all the same, and one might justifiably suspect, engaged in a “joint venture.”

However, as to opportunity and proximity, the Zetas’ AOR (area of responsibility), i.e., their territory and their resources are the closest with easy access to the target area.

Furthermore, at the moment, some degree of desperation may be setting in as the Zetas are under relentless attack on both sides of the border by the Trump Administration, and with the prospect of “The Wall” blocking their trade routes into the US market, the Zeta’s are zealous and highly motivated to strike terror into the very hearts and minds of the Amercian people.  The pressure that President Trump is putting on the Mexian government is bearing down on them and the US Border Patrol unshackled from the tethers and restraints of the Obama Administration pro-narcoterrorist border policies, the fuutre for the Zetas looks very grim indeed.

The “Gangbusters style” of prosecution that has been the hallmark of Attorney General Jeff Sessions’ use of the Department of Justice and the FBI in dismantling “M-13” by arresting, jailing and deporting members of the vast MS-13 narcotrafficking gangs, i.e., the Zetas distribution network across the U.S. is being destroyed and that surely puts The Zetas high on this reporter’s on the suspect list.


Not a word of “Alllahu Akbar” Heard In Las Vegas?

Has there ever been an Al-Queda or ISIS attack anywhere where the words: “Allahu Akbar” weren’t heard or squealed by a dying suicide bomber?

I can’t recall any major attacks by Jihadis when the terrorists weren’t shouting or squeaking “Allahu Akbar” (which by the way has been designated a capital crime by the Italian Government, which has called upon Italian Carabinieri (police) to shoot on sight ANYONE who utters, screams or yells out “ALLAHU AKBAR” in any public setting!

If ISIS or Al-Queda are to blame for this massacre, that would make the Las Vegas attack the first major attack in which the words “ALLAHU AKBAR” were not heard (exept on Twitter).  This point reinforces  my observation, made previously, regarding the significance of the altercation that occured in the crowd 45 minutes before the shooting started.

It is clear that the words “ALLAHU AKBAR” nor anything akin to them were heard by anyone in the crowd.  If they were, it was not and has not been reported.

I think that the reader would agree that foreknoweldge of such a dastardly event would clearly imply that an association existed between those who knew before the event and those who perpetrated the deed.

All reports describing the 2 people who were caught up in the dispute and removed from the venue were described as a “Hispanics,” namely, man and a woman about 5 feet 5 or 6 inches, who was described as the instigator of the fracas and who shouted with an Hispanic accent.

And here, we face another paradox.

ISIS has openly been claiming responsibility for the attack since Day 2 …

and paradooxically, the Las Vegas Police & FBI deny and dismiss it, but is an established FACT that ISIS’ Warned 2 American Cities of impending attacks more than a week before the Las Vegas attack and Las Vegas was shown to be an intended target in the video warning.

It is an established and ecorded fact that more than a week before the killings, ISIS issued a dire and menacing warning to Las Vegas and to the city of San Francisco via Twitter that attacks were planned for those cities in the very near future.

NBC News in Las Vegas carried the report and did an extended feature story with city and police officials commenting on the implied threats, but diminishing their importance, if not dismissing them altogether.

This writer has seen that report several times and would note for the reader, that the ISIS warning (picked up on Twitter) threatening both cities, chose to show San Francisco’s Golden Bay Bridge to represent San Francisco, and remarkably, showed a panoramic photograph of The Black  Pyramind-Madalay Bay Hotel area precisely where the massace would occur about 10 days later.

Was Las Vegas a Terrorist Co-op or an FBI “Sting Operation” Gone Wrong?

It is possible, given the networking nature of terrorist cells, that more than one terrorist organization was involved.  In fact, given the wworld wide terrorist communications in drug smuggling and arms dealings, it would not be unreasonable to believe that ISIS or Al-Queda could have contracted technical asssistance from the Zetas to conduct the operation.  Or any one of them could have been lured into a planned FBI sting in which Steven Paddack was acting as a go-between for the FBI in arranging an arms sale that would have been the basis of the “FBI Sting Operation,”

It has also been discovered that Steven Pollack journeyed overseas more than 20 times and that he visited Jordan and the United Arab Emirates,  where he could have been radicalized by ISIS or some other terrorist cell.  Or he could have been there on a covert mission for one of our intelligence agencies, either the  CIA or the FBI.  he possibility that this was another case of “Fast & Furious” gone wrong is not out of the question, and quite a reasonable explanation for “what went down” that igh in Las Vegas.

It is important to note, as we have learned in recent years, that ISIS was created and funded by the US, Israel and Jordan who set up an operational headquarters in Amman, Jordan to oversee the creation of ISIS to establish  a “SALAFIST PRINICIPALITY” (quoted from a leaked Pentagon memo of August 2014).

This so-called “Salafist Principality” is one and the same “Caliphate” of Abu-Bakir al-Bagdhadi (i.e. the ‘Salafist prince” referred to in the Pentagon memo) that the Obama and Clinton State Department wanted to use to destabilize Syria and depose Bashar Assad.

The Pentagon memo was released last year during the Presidential campaign by WikiLeaks founder, Julian Assange.

It appears from current information that Steven Pollack may have been working with the FBI or another Federal agency in an arms deal with a terrorist group and that the plan backfired badly with the terrorists discovering Pollack’s true identity.   This resulted in his execution and the carrying out of the coordinated attacks during a 15 minute period with the culprits getting away “Scott Free” and leaving Pollack’s dead body as a patsy behind (like Lee Harvey Oswald) to “take the rap.”

Robert Morningstar

New York City

October 21st, 2017



October 22st, 2017

Richard Hoagland & Robert Morningtar Discuss the Las Vegas Attacks

on October 22nd, 2017.

Tune in to


at 12 Midnight   Eastern 11 Central   10 p.m. Mountain   9 p.m. Pacific to:

Robert Morningstar’s Items

for The Other Side of Midnight Broadsast October 22nd  2017:

1- Aerial view of Mandalay Bay, Las Vegas, Nevada.

I’ve corellated these 2 videos with external photos of the hotel to triangulate the postion of the shooter.

There were no broken windows in that area of the hotel.  Using the POV of the Taxi Driver as she was aligned with the corner of the roof structure that covers the drive through access road, video analsis places the shooter atop the green rooftop seen in the photo above.  Below is video proof exposing the postion of the shooter(s):

This Las Vegas Taxi Driver’s Video caught a shooter firing from the lower floor of the Mandalay Bay from a very close vantage point, i.e. pulling out of the Mandalay’s Drive-Though entrance.This is amazing…I believe that this is indisputable proof and is consonant with the 1st video I sent you earlier, i.e. the stable video shot from the hotel across the street.  I’ve put both links together below.


Between Time Mark 4:39 and 4:52, we can hear the sounds of TWO (2) separate automatic weapons, each firing at a different rate of fire, one faster than the other. The sounds coming from one of the weapons is louder (with deeper sounding report of a higher caliber weapon) and one sounds much closer than the other.

2-  Vegas Shooting Taxi Driver’s Video


3- Video from the hotel across the street.

I have calculated the shooter’s position to be outside the hotel and shooting from a rooftop that covers the passanger drop-off area of the entrance of the hotel. 

4-  Taxi lady’s video captures unique shots that are on NO other video or audio captured at such close range.

However, there are 13 faint shots fired that she describes as “far away”.
This audio analysis proves beyond doubt that there were more than one gunman shooting and several times firing at the same time.  NO other video captures them.  So they were either INSIDE the hotel or South of Mandalay Bay.
The gun sounds are like those of an AK-47 or and M-240 belt fed machine-gun, for at least 9 of the 11 volleys.  If you were hit with that it would leave a big hole.
However, the pictures of Paddock’s room contained only AR-15s, which fire .223 caliber ammo (aka 556 mm. NATO rounds).   The majority of injuries appear to be more consistent with AR-15, not AK-47 round.

(Posted by Bizzy Vlogs)

5- Iron-Clad Forensic Acoustic Analysis Proof of Multiple Shooters  

Lag time between the arrival of the shots and the report of the weapons proves the presence of 2 shooters who were firing from different distances 400 meters and 250 meters.

(Posted by HighImpactFlix)

6. Rocky Palmero’s Wound Proves Shooters Were Inside the venue and Soros Financial Investments in the Las Vegas Attacks. 

(Posted by Cut2The Truth)

7-   Numerologically, the date is extremely significant:


October 1, 2017

10/01/2017 (= 2+0+1+7)
“October First” also = “OctoberFest”
Octoberfest is a Christian derivation from an ancient pagan harvest ritual.
JFK was also shot in the midst of a Masonic temple near the banks of the Trinity River and the main hub of the MILINT radio command and control center that was directing Air Force 1’s radio transmissions was also designated “TRINITY.”




We in this country, in this generation, are by destiny rather than choice, thewatchmen on the walls of world freedom. 

We ask, therefore, that we may be worthy of our power and responsibility, that we may exercise our strength with wisdom and restraint, and that we may achieve in our time and for all time the ancient vision of peace on earth, goodwill toward men …

That must always be our goal and the righteousness of our cause must always underlie our strength.

For as was written long ago: 

 ‘Except the Lord keep the city, the watchman waketh but in vain.’”

 John Fitzgerald Kennedy


Robert Morningstar is a civilian intelligence analyst, investigative journalist and psychotherapist, living in New York City.

Robert is a specialist in photo interpretation, geometric analysis and computer imaging. Robert Morningstar is a graduate of Power Memorial Academy and was a New York State Regents Scholar (1967-72) at Fordham University where he received a degree in psychology.  While at Fordham University, in 1969, Robert participated as a research fellow in a US Navy-sponsored program to develop Artificial Intelligence

Robert Morningstar is a FAA-licensed private pilot and Instrument Ground Instructor and has studied the paranormal and UFOs for over 50 years and published many research articles on the Internet, exposing government cover-up and deception applied in the JFK Assassination.

Robert has written extensively to expose CIA, FBI, and NASA’s use of “Disinformation Technology” to suppress evidence in the JFK Assassination and suppressing proof of an extraterrestrial presence on on the Moon.


Robert is currently the Publisher & Editor of UFO Digest, which exposes the real nature and menace of the UFO phenomenon and the threat its cover-up poses to our constitutional liberties.